Ius Omnibus welcomes the European Commission's proposed Digital Fairness Act as an important step towards stronger consumer protection.
However, the proposal can and should go further in tackling digital manipulation, improving access to evidence, and ensuring effective enforcement.
Read our full statement below.
Ius Omnibus welcomes the European Commission's proposal for a Digital Fairness Act (DFA), an important step towards adapting European consumer protection law to the realities of the digital economy.
For years, digital businesses have been able to exploit information asymmetries, behavioural vulnerabilities, and technological opacity to influence consumer decisions. Practices such as manipulative interfaces, addictive design, and unfair personalisation have become widespread features of digital services. The Commission's proposal recognises that European consumer law must evolve to address these challenges.
Ius Omnibus particularly welcomes the proposed prohibition of manipulative interface designs (dark patterns), including a blacklist of practices considered unfair in all circumstances. The proposal also introduces important safeguards against misleading influencer marketing, subscription traps, exploitative video-game monetisation, and certain forms of personalised advertising and pricing. Its measures to facilitate access to technical evidence are equally welcome. For consumers, these changes could mean fewer misleading prompts, clearer prices and advertising, greater protection for children in online games, and simpler ways to cancel subscriptions or avoid unwanted renewals.
The replacement of the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive with a directly applicable Regulation, together with the proposed reform of the Consumer Protection Cooperation framework, represents another significant step towards more consistent consumer protection across the European Union, by reducing differences in national implementation and strengthening coordinated enforcement against cross-border infringements.
However, recognising the problems is only the first step. The DFA should go further in addressing the business practices that create and perpetuate them, and it must create effective public and private enforcement mechanisms to make the regulation workable and enforceable in practice.
Of particular concern to Ius Omnibus is the legal uncertainty which the proposal could create for consumer collective redress in the EU. Although the Representative Actions Directive (RAD) remains applicable, the proposal’s own complex enforcement framework does not sufficiently clarify its relationship with the RAD and collective consumer actions overall. The final text should remove any uncertainty and explicitly safeguard the ability of qualified consumer organisations to challenge infringements on behalf of consumers. It should also preserve Member States' ability to maintain or introduce broader collective-redress mechanisms, as permitted by the RAD.
Also, an area of concern is the regulation of addictive design. The proposal recognises that certain features are designed to encourage compulsive or excessive use, yet Article 17 DFA largely responds by requiring businesses to allow consumers to disable them. Why should the responsibility for avoiding potentially harmful features fall primarily on consumers rather than on the businesses that design and profit from them? Ius Omnibus considers that safer design should be the default, accompanied by stronger obligations to prevent exploitative practices from the outset.
Another fundamental challenge is the individualisation of commercial manipulation. European consumer law traditionally assesses unfair practices against the standard of the average consumer or the average member of a vulnerable group. Yet, digital businesses can increasingly identify and exploit the particular vulnerabilities of individual consumers through algorithmic profiling. Although the European Commission's 2021 Guidance on the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive recognises that highly personalised practices may require individualised assessments, the proposal fails to expressly consolidate this approach and adopts a narrower formulation of the circumstances giving rise to enhanced protection.
The restrictions on personalised advertising also remain incomplete. While the prohibition of advertising based on special categories of personal data is welcomed, businesses can exploit vulnerabilities that fall outside those categories, such as financial distress or susceptibility to compulsive spending. Consumer protection should not depend on whether a particular vulnerability happens to fall within the GDPR's definition of sensitive personal data. The Regulation should address such exploitative practices without encouraging additional intrusive profiling.
Ius Omnibus also considers that the proposal could go further in facilitating access to evidence. Although Article 34 DFA introduces important improvements, consumers and consumer organisations may still face difficulties demonstrating the likelihood of an infringement when the necessary evidence is exclusively controlled by the business concerned. The Regulation should account for these information asymmetries and establish appropriate mechanisms to preserve technical evidence, particularly where algorithms and digital interfaces are constantly modified.
The DFA is an important opportunity to establish a European digital economy in which businesses compete through innovation, quality and consumer trust, rather than through their ability to exploit consumers' vulnerabilities.
Ius Omnibus welcomes the Commission's initiative and looks forward to contributing constructively to the legislative process. The European Parliament and Member States now have an opportunity to build on this proposal, strengthening its safeguards and ensuring that the final Regulation addresses not only the consequences of digital manipulation, but also the commercial practices that enable it.